Cattedra Rotelli

Cattedra Rotelli

Cattedra Rotelli 2021 - Prof. Seyla Benhabib

The Seduction of Sovereignty – Sovereignty, Democracy and Human Rights from a Cosmopolitan Perspective

2–6 November 2021
 

The fifth edition of the Rotelli Lectures at Vita-Salute San Raffaele University welcomed Seyla Benhabib, political philosopher and critical theorist, Senior Research Scholar and Adjunct Professor of Law at Columbia Law School, for a series of five lectures entitled The Seduction of Sovereignty. A Democratic and Cosmopolitan Critique.

Exploring the relationship between sovereignty, democracy and human rights, Benhabib examined the transformations of political power in contemporary societies, investigating how state autonomy can be reconciled with universal principles of justice and the challenges posed by migration and supranational institutions.

Lecture themes: sovereignty, democracy, international law and cosmopolitanism

The five lectures focused on political sovereignty, examining its philosophical origins, historical transformations and the tensions it creates within contemporary democracies. Benhabib explored the enduring appeal of the sovereign state, questioning its limitations in a world increasingly shaped by global interdependence, supranational institutions and claims to rights that extend beyond national borders.

The series began with a historical reconstruction of the concept of sovereignty, paying particular attention to Thomas Hobbes and his contribution to the development of modern political authority. The discussion then turned to the transformations brought about by constitutionalism and judicial review, examining the role of institutions and constitutional principles in defining and limiting the exercise of sovereign power.

Another central theme concerned the relationship between state sovereignty and international law, with particular emphasis on the legitimacy of supranational norms and the possibility of reconciling democratic self-determination with universal obligations and principles of justice.

The final lectures addressed the relationship between popular sovereignty, political membership and human rights, raising the question of who can be recognised as part of the demos, the community of citizens exercising democratic power. Particular attention was devoted to the "right to have rights", especially in relation to those who find themselves at the margins of, or excluded from, established political communities, including migrants and individuals without full legal recognition.

Bringing together political philosophy, constitutionalism and cosmopolitanism, the series offered a critique of absolute conceptions of sovereignty, highlighting the need to reconsider the boundaries of democratic membership and the relationship between political authority and the universal protection of rights.

The five lectures of the 2021 edition

Program of the Rotelli Lectures 2021 (online):

  • 2 Novembre, 16.00 – 18.30
    Lecture 1: “The Adventures of Sovereignty”
    Discussant: Raffaele Ariano (CRISI, ICONE)
  • 3 Novembre, 16.00 – 18.30
    Lecture 2: “In the Beginning was Thomas Hobbes”
    Discussant: Giacomo Arrigo (IRCECP)
  • 4 Novembre, 16.00 – 18.30
    Lecture 3: “Transformation of Sovereignty. Constitutionalism and Judicial Review”
    Discussant: Francesca Cesarano (CeSEP)
  • 5 Novembre, 16.00 – 18.30
    Lecture 4: "Sovereignty and the Legitimacy of International Law"
    Discussant: Alessandro Volpe (IRCECP) 
  • 6 Novembre, 16.00 – 18.30
    Lecture 5: “The ‘Right to have Rights’: Popular Sovereignty and the Boundaries of the Demos”
    Discussant: Mitja Sardoč (ERI (Ljubljana), CeSEP) 

Useful Links